USA: Virginia Prince Who Built The First Trans Organisation Loathed Homosexuals, Arguing In The Future Transvestitism Would Be Considered Normal, But People Would Never Accept Homosexuality.

4./ Prince loathed homosexuals, arguing in the future transvestitism would be considered normal, but people would never accept homosexuality. Here's Harvey Fierstein who met Prince saying this at a promotional event for Casa Susanna. He'd written an earlier play about the resort. pic.twitter.com/kuaXp5uxVW

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

6./ This dissociative attitude meant that Virginia (Arnold) who insisted he was heterosexual and banned homosexuals from FPE could argue his "female" personality was a heterosexual woman and that was why "she" slept with heterosexual men. Fierstein again, at the end of the clip. pic.twitter.com/01iJBk4ht4

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

1./ What's the darkest secret of the trans lobby? It's one it's tried to hide for decades. There's a clue in this documentary on the BBC, called 'Casa Susanna'.
It's a sexual fetish of men who get off by imagining themselves as women.
1/ of 10
👇https://t.co/wMWKjVSPQJ

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

2./ In my latest substack I explore autogynephilia (or AGP) revealing that the fetish was the driving motive of the first trans organisation of which Casa Susanna, a transvestite holiday resort in the Catskills, was an important affilliate. https://t.co/0yW60tk7Da

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

3./ A regular guest was the man who invented the word transgender and whom Susan Stryker the trans historian says was a "crucial figure in the early transgender movement", Virginia Prince (Arnold Lowman) who built that first trans organisation, Full Personality Expression. pic.twitter.com/N3eXArV01o

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

5./ Virginia embodied the delusionary quality of the trans narrative. He believed trans people had dual personalities and with enough determination a man could create a real, three dimensional female personality that was actually psychically separate from the male personality. pic.twitter.com/PUxUaHxEg7

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

7./ At the heart of Casa Susanna was sexual fetishism. Autogynephilia and this 'sissy fetish' where men like to be humiliated, dressed as women, are closely linked. It was a feature of Virginia Prince's magazine Transvestia for which the owner of Casa wrote a regular column. pic.twitter.com/GLMQJywk81

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

8./ The trans lobby was horrified when a book was published in 2003 that revealed the extent of trans autogynephilia to the public. A vicious campaign against the author @profjmb was launched, his family was targetted and petitions demanded his sacking. pic.twitter.com/ZyhjJz0dgY

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

9./ That champion of academic freedom Stephen Whittle participated in the bullying. Of course she did. The trans lobby's claims are couched in terms of social justice. That sympathy would evaporate if the public thought up to half of transwomen were driven by a sexual fetish.

— Malcolm Clark (@TwisterFilm) April 16, 2023

The Secret Gender Files

AGP and the Sissies of Casa Susanna

written Malcolm Richard Clark

Tuesday April 18, 2023

If you want to understand today's trans movement a good place to start is a recent BBC film about a 1960s transvestite resort. Coyness about sexual fetishism is its lasting legacy.

Casa Susanna is an enigmatic and dark little film. Which is kind of strange given it tries so hard to be an uplifting one about people struggling heroically to be their authentic truthy true selves.

Commissioned by Arté and Storyville at the BBC it tells the fascinating story of “an oasis of acceptance”, Casa Susanna, a modest holiday resort tucked away in the Catskills that catered for secretive transvestites in the 1950s and 60s. There they dressed in the ladies’ fashions of the day while engaging in polite social activities. One of those was taking snapshots of each other, though let’s just say sometimes their enthusiasm is more noticeable than their politeness.

Is this enthusiasm a little hot under the collar….or brassiere?

That question will not be asked in this film, and that’s a shame. There are innumerable moments where the viewer feels what has been left out is more interesting than what we’re watching.

Above all, there is hardly a shadow, or breath of…sex.

While it touches briefly on the situation of gay men, who at the time faced legal penalties for having sex, it portays the transvestites as almost entirely sexless creatures. Bosoms up, stockings being rolled up legs, head tilts agogo but it’s very much No sex please we’re in the Catskills.

Here’s the trailer:

BFI Published September 12, 2022: CASA SUSANNA trailer | BFI London Film Festival 2022. Sébastien Lifshitz pieces together the story of a pioneering transgender network in this inspiring and essential slice of queer history.

In 1960 Virginia Prince founded Transvestia magazine https://t.co/O6JcChoA1D pic.twitter.com/DUJ1u2MJOj

— Dani 🌼 (@ashatteredyouth) March 23, 2023

It’s crazy to read the history of organised transvestism and their biggest advocate, Virginia Prince. He tried to normalise being a “male woman”, was incredibly hostile to transsexuals and SRS — deeming us transvestites who went too far, and constantly promoted “gender euphoria”

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

In recent weeks a lesbian woman and a gay man have been violently assaulted by trans activists but don’t expect to hear about this from the mainstream media because it challenges their narrative of the LGBT rainbow community.

— Venice Allan (@roseveniceallan) April 18, 2023

Didn't 'Virginia Prince', who coined the word transgender in the 60s, refuse to allow gay and lesbian people to join his trans organisation?

— Ali L 96.5% (@Alichat66) April 18, 2023

Back in the day, “Virginia Prince” used to speak to community college Human Sexuality classes, which fulfilled a science requirement. As an impressionable young student, I saw him speak twice. Quite a piece of work!

— Belissa Cohen #NoFemaleLanguage4Men (@BelissaCohen) April 17, 2023

Resorting to labels & threats when faced with a challenging perspective?

True transsexuals have a unique and medically based experience that shouldn't be conflated with gender ideology.

Your inability to acknowledge this exposes your stance's fragility. #TranssexualSeparatism

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 5, 2023

“Transgender” is a construct invented by transvestites like Holly Boswell and Virginia Prince, which queer theorists seized upon to further their mission of abolishing gender in society.

If being pro-transsexual means I’m anti-transgender, so be it.#EndTheTransgenderUmbrella

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 12, 2023

I added this picture message above to connect with tweets below.

1/ Let’s discuss the Big Lie, a tactic used to keep transsexuals within the #Transgender umbrella & silence our dissent.

A big lie is a gross distortion of the truth, often used in #propaganda. 🧵 pic.twitter.com/7UEd5Jl5ZQ

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

2/ The expression was coined by Adolf Hitler in Mein Kampf to describe the use of a lie so colossal that no one would believe that someone "could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously."

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

3/ Hitler claimed the technique was used by Jews to blame Germany's loss in WWI on German general Erich Ludendorff, a prominent nationalist in the Weimar Republic. This original big lie was built on by the Nazis to compel the German people to endorse their ideological policies.

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

4/ Our emotions make us susceptible to big lies, as Hitler articulated:

“In the big lie there is always a certain force of credibility; because the broad masses [are] more easily corrupted in their emotional nature than consciously or voluntarily; ….

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

5/ and thus in the primitive simplicity of their minds they more readily fall victims to the big lie than the small lie, since they themselves often tell small lies in little matters but would be ashamed to resort to large-scale falsehoods. It would never come into their heads…

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

7/ For Goebbels, it had this definition:

“If those in authority repeat an outrageous falsehood over and over, and there is no countervailing voice exposing this big lie to the public, or if that voice is censored by the media, the big lie is likely to be believed.”

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

8/ Implicit in the Big Lie is intimidation. If a minority group is accused, based on their stance, of being the devil by the majority in a stated Big Lie, it places the minority in a defensive position that calls for either rebuttal or capitulation in the face of more Big Lies

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

10/ Here's how it works:

Transsexuals: “We appreciate that nondysphoric people exist, but grouping us together is bad because our struggle is medical and sx-based.”

Transgender enforcers: “How dare they! They have determined that we do not exist for they say they are not us.”

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

12/ Majority response with a bigger lie:

Non-TS TG: “If TS is not like us they are saying we don’t exist. They are out to eliminate us. They want nothing more than to erase all those TG.”#EndTheTransgenderUmbrella#TranssexualSeparatism

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

It's quite simple really.

I once asked Julia Serano, why as she acknowledged transsexuals are materially different than the rest of the umbrella, why they can't just let us be a separate thing.

Julia said, "without us, the rest of trans a complete non starter."

— Overthinking (@Overthi34255577) April 10, 2023

Exactly. Serano has held back on denouncing the umbrella outright, but she effectively highlights how transsexuals are adversely affected by it

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

The obfuscation of transsexuals began a long time ago with a lifestyle crossdresser named Arnold Loman, aka Charles Virginia Prince

Every bit of the insanity which has erased us springs from seeds he sowed, starting late 1950s through the 1990s

Serano built on that foundation

— Overthinking (@Overthi34255577) April 10, 2023

I’ve read Prince’s history. I’ve never felt so much palpable rage towards a dead person; they were absolutely vile towards transsexuals.

Any suggested reads beyond Serrano?

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

Unfortunately no and the problem is the constant retconning of our history to reflect not what actually happened, but how people want it to have happened, and if even that's inconvenient? To simply erase it as they have with transsexuals.

— Overthinking (@Overthi34255577) April 10, 2023

Yeah, it’s ridiculous. Modern trans(vestite) histories just gloss over it completely.

No surprise when I read elsewhere that Stryker was one of those who didn’t feel transsexual fit right.

The best sources are decades out of date, from before the transgender umbrella

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

It's sad really how much has been lost, take Reid Erikson, heir to a sizable fortune and one of the very first FtMs. He personally bankrolled Harry Benjamin and much of the early research into TS was because of him, but his name is now all but forgotten.

— Overthinking (@Overthi34255577) April 10, 2023

@HeterodoxTakes and I are working on a project to lobby for the separation of transsexualism from GNC people in discourse, policy, and legislation.

We would love for you to be involved if you would be interested. Re-establishing our history is a critical component

— Morgan 🇬🇧🇺🇸 (@transmedscum) April 10, 2023

The lumping together under the 'trans umbrella' of many obviously different groups seems bonkers to me, especially after the increase in people identifying as trans, but could anyone get funding to study this?

— Gabrielle Ravenclaw 💚🤍💜 (@gabissima) April 10, 2023

It's a noble cause, but alas the deck is stacked against you because there are so very very few of us and soooooo many of them and they have a vested interest in keeping the waters as muddy as possible.

— Overthinking (@Overthi34255577) April 11, 2023